Reviews and testimonials are some of the most persuasive things on a small business website, which is exactly why regulators watch them closely. In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission finalised a rule on consumer reviews and testimonials in August 2024, and it took effect on October 21, 2024. It targets fake and manipulated reviews directly and lets the FTC seek civil penalties against businesses that knowingly break it. Here is what it covers and how to collect reviews in a way that stays on the right side of it.
What the Rule Bans
The rule groups several practices together. In plain terms, businesses must not:
- Create, buy or sell fake reviews or testimonials, including ones that claim to come from people who do not exist, such as AI-generated reviews, or from people who never actually used the product or service.
- Offer something in return for a review that has to be positive or negative. Rewards that depend on the review's sentiment are banned.
- Publish reviews from owners, managers or staff without clearly disclosing their connection to the business.
- Present a review website as independent when the business controls it and its own products are among those being reviewed.
- Suppress negative reviews through unfounded legal threats, intimidation or false accusations, or hide negative reviews while presenting the rest as the full picture.
- Buy or sell fake signs of social media influence, such as bot followers or fake views, for commercial purposes.
The rule looks at reviews and testimonials wherever they appear, including your own website, social media posts, ads and outside review sites. It covers businesses that write or sell fake reviews as well as the businesses that buy them.
Who It Affects
The rule applies to businesses of any size marketing to people in the United States, not only large brands and review platforms. It also matters if you pay someone else to manage your reputation: an agency, freelancer or review "service" that posts fake reviews on your behalf creates the same problem for you. The FTC has already sent warning letters to companies it believed might be breaking the rule, so this is not a rule that sits quietly on the books.
Outside the United States, consumer protection laws in many countries also treat fake reviews as misleading advertising. If you sell elsewhere, check your local rules.
What Is Still Fine
- Asking every customer for an honest review. Ask all of them, not only the ones you expect to be happy; some review platforms explicitly ban selective requests.
- Offering a small thank-you that does not depend on what the customer writes. This rule does not ban it, but the FTC's endorsement guidance expects such incentives to be disclosed, and many review platforms ban incentives entirely. Check their rules first.
- Replying to negative reviews politely and offering to fix the problem.
- Moderating reviews that are spam, abusive, off-topic or contain private information, as long as you apply the same standards to positive and negative reviews.
- Reviews from staff where the connection is clearly disclosed.
A Clean-Up Checklist
- Audit the testimonials on your website. Each one should come from a real customer, in their own words, with permission to use it.
- Remove or clearly label reviews from yourself, your family or your staff.
- Stop any review swaps, paid review packages or follower purchases, and ask any agency or freelancer working on your reputation exactly how they get results.
- Do not use AI to invent testimonials or "example" reviews, even as placeholders on a new site.
- Write down your moderation rules and apply them to every review regardless of its rating.
- Keep records of where each testimonial came from and the permission you received.
Next Step
Set up one honest review request that goes to every customer after a purchase or appointment, with a direct link to where you want reviews to appear. A steady stream of genuine reviews does more for trust than any shortcut, and it keeps you well clear of the rule.