Every time a good tenant moves out, you face cleaning, repairs, new photos, showings, screening and often several weeks without rent. Keeping a reliable tenant for another year is usually the cheapest and least stressful outcome for a small landlord. Yet renewals are often handled at the last minute, with a short note and a rent increase that arrives as a surprise.
Most leases, and many local laws, require a minimum notice period before a lease ends or before rent changes. Even where the required notice is short, starting the conversation 60 to 90 days before the end date gives both sides time to plan. A tenant who is unsure has room to decide, and if they plan to leave, you have time to prepare and list the unit without a long gap.
Put the lease end date, and the latest date you can send a renewal offer, on your calendar the day each lease is signed.
A short, friendly conversation before the formal offer tells you a lot. Ask whether they plan to stay, whether anything in the home needs attention and whether anything would make the next year better. You may learn about a repair that has been bothering them, or that they are thinking about moving for work. Either way, you can respond before it turns into a surprise.
Look at current comparable listings, the same way you would when pricing a vacant unit, and at your own costs, such as property taxes, insurance and maintenance. Then weigh that against the cost of turnover. For many small landlords, a modest increase for a reliable tenant earns more over time than pushing to full market rent and risking a vacancy.
A worked example: suppose market rent has risen by $100 a month, but turnover would cost you a month of rent plus cleaning and repairs. Renewing a good tenant with a $50 increase gives up $600 over the year, which is often less than a single vacant month. Run your own numbers, and check whether rent increase limits or notice rules apply where your property is.
The written renewal offer should leave no room for confusion. Include:
If you offer choices, keep them simple, for example a 12-month renewal at one rent or a shorter term at a slightly higher rent. Put the final agreement in writing and give the tenant a signed copy.
The decision to renew is shaped over the whole year, not in the week the offer arrives. Things that often matter more to tenants than a small difference in rent:
At renewal time, a small improvement can help too: fresh paint, an appliance that was due for replacement anyway, a professional carpet clean or a better light fixture. These improve your property, so they hold their value either way.
Thank them, confirm the move-out date in writing and explain the move-out process, including the inspection and the deposit timeline. Ask whether they would allow showings during the last few weeks, with proper notice, so you can find the next tenant sooner. Ask for honest feedback as well. Comments about noise, parking or a recurring repair can point to your next improvement.
Adjust these dates to match your lease and any notice periods that apply where you are.