Most security deposit disputes come down to one question: what condition was the home in when the tenant moved in? Without a clear record, it becomes one person's memory against another's. A careful, documented inspection at both ends of a lease is the simplest way to avoid that argument.
Create one condition report and use it for both inspections. List every room, and within each room the same items in the same order. That way, the move-out notes sit right beside the move-in notes and differences are easy to spot. Some states and cities require a specific form, or require you to give tenants a copy within a set time, so check local rules.
A typical item list for each room:
Then add room-specific items: appliances, counters, cabinets and sink in the kitchen; toilet, tub or shower, grout, exhaust fan and vanity in bathrooms; smoke and carbon monoxide detectors wherever they are installed.
Inviting the tenant makes the record more credible and lets you settle small disagreements on the spot. Go room by room, describe each item and agree on the wording. Use specific notes rather than single words: "two-inch scratch on the floor near the closet door" is far more useful later than "floor fair." Both of you sign and date the finished form, and each keeps a copy.
Photos back up the written notes. A few habits make them much more useful:
Run the taps, flush the toilets, test the appliances and open every window during the inspection, so you document what works and not just how things look.
In many places, landlords cannot charge tenants for normal wear and tear, only for damage beyond it. Where the line falls depends on local law and on how long the tenant lived there, but common examples look like this:
| Usually normal wear | Usually damage |
|---|---|
| Light scuffs and faded paint | Large holes, unapproved paint colors, crayon or marker on walls |
| Carpet worn along walkways | Burns, large stains or pet damage |
| A few small nail holes from pictures | Broken doors, windows or blinds |
| Door handles loosened by years of use | Missing fixtures or appliances |
| Minor surface scratches on floors | Deep gouges, or water damage from neglect |
Finishes also lose value with age, which many places take into account when deciding what a fair charge would be.
Before the tenant leaves, consider offering a pre-move-out walkthrough so they can fix small issues themselves; some places require you to offer one. After the keys are returned, do the final inspection with the same form, compare it line by line with the move-in report and take matching photos from the same angles.
If you deduct anything from the deposit, list each item with a description and cost, and attach receipts or estimates where you can. Most places set a deadline for returning the deposit or sending an itemized statement, sometimes as short as a couple of weeks, so put that date on your calendar the day the tenant moves out.