NFT

NFT Royalties Explained: Why They Are Not Guaranteed

November 3, 2026 4 min read
NFT Royalties Explained: Why They Are Not Guaranteed

One of the most repeated promises about NFTs was that artists would earn a royalty every time their work resold, automatically and forever. For many creators, that was the main appeal. The reality is more complicated. Royalties can work, but they depend on choices made by marketplaces and buyers, not only on the blockchain. If you are planning to mint, it is worth knowing how they function before you count on them.

What an NFT royalty is

A royalty on an NFT is a percentage of a secondary sale, meaning a resale after the first purchase, that goes back to the original creator. If a collector resells your work, a portion of that sale price is sent to a wallet you chose. The percentage is set by the creator, usually when the collection is created.

This is different from much of the traditional art market, where artists often receive nothing from resales except in places with specific resale-right laws.

Why royalties are not built into the token

Here is the key point: a basic NFT transfer does not include a payment step. Moving a token from one wallet to another is just a transfer. The sale price, if there is one, is handled by the marketplace or by a separate arrangement between buyer and seller.

On Ethereum, a standard called EIP-2981 lets a contract report what royalty the creator would like paid and to whom. But reporting is not the same as enforcing. The standard tells marketplaces what the creator requested. It does not force anyone to pay it. Royalties have generally been paid because marketplaces chose to collect and forward them.

Why marketplaces differ

Marketplaces compete for traders, and lower fees attract traders. Over time, some marketplaces have made royalties optional for buyers, set minimums, or enforced them only for certain collections. Others continue to honor creator settings. Policies have changed more than once and may change again, so check the current terms of any marketplace you use rather than relying on what you heard months ago.

A token can also be sold without any marketplace at all. Two people can agree on a price, send the payment separately, and transfer the token directly. In that case no royalty is collected unless the buyer chooses to pay one.

Enforcement tools and their trade-offs

Some contracts try to enforce royalties by restricting which marketplaces or contracts can transfer the token. This can protect income, but it comes with costs:

  • Collectors may find they cannot list the work on their preferred platform.
  • Restrictions can feel at odds with the idea that the holder controls the token.
  • The rules depend on contract code, which needs to be written and reviewed carefully.
  • Some approaches can be worked around, for example by wrapping the token inside another contract.

There is no single right answer. Some artists prefer open transfers and treat royalties as a bonus. Others prioritize enforcement and accept a smaller set of marketplaces.

Planning your income realistically

If NFTs are part of how you earn a living, treat royalties as uncertain. The primary sale, meaning the first time a piece sells, is the income you can most directly control. Resale activity is unpredictable. Many works never resell at all, and NFT markets have gone through long quiet periods. None of this is financial advice, and selling digital work this way carries real risk.

Many artists combine NFT sales with other income: commissions, prints, licensing deals, teaching or memberships. Royalties, when they arrive, are one stream among several rather than the foundation.

Royalty checklist before you mint

  • Decide what royalty percentage you will request and write down why.
  • Check how each marketplace you plan to use currently handles royalties.
  • Ask whether your minting tool supports a royalty standard and whether it adds any transfer restrictions.
  • Tell collectors plainly how royalties work for your collection.
  • Do not build a budget that depends on resale royalties.
  • Keep records of any royalty payments you receive for tax purposes.