Tenants who plan to stay a while want the place to feel like home. Sooner or later, someone will ask to paint a bedroom, mount a television, put up shelves, install a smart thermostat or swap a light fixture. Saying no to everything can push good tenants to leave, or to do the work quietly anyway. Saying yes without terms can leave you with a purple wall and a dozen holes at move-out. A simple policy lets you say yes to reasonable requests while protecting the property.
Your lease should say that tenants need written permission before making alterations, and give examples of what counts: painting, drilling into walls, changing locks, replacing fixtures, installing appliances and any work involving plumbing or electrical systems. Then decide in advance where you stand on common requests, so you answer every tenant consistently:
Some changes, such as modifications a tenant with a disability needs, may come with specific rules about whether you must allow them and who pays. Check your local rules and respond to those requests carefully and promptly.
Ask tenants to put every request in writing with enough detail to decide: what they want to do, where, the materials or product, who will do the work and when. For paint, ask for the exact color and finish. For a mounted television, ask what kind of mount it is and whether it will be fixed into studs. A photo of the wall or a picture of the product helps you picture the result.
For each request, ask yourself:
If the answers are mostly reassuring, approve the request with conditions. If not, explain why and offer an alternative, such as having your own handyman do the work or suggesting a removable option.
A short written approval prevents most disputes at move-out. It should state:
Both of you should sign it, and it should go in the tenancy file with a photo of the area before work starts. Depending on your lease and local rules, items fixed to the building may become part of the property, so state clearly whether anything will be removed when the tenant leaves.
Once the work is finished, ask for a photo or arrange a brief visit with proper notice to see it. Note the change in your property records, such as the new paint color for future touch-ups or the model of a new thermostat. At move-out, compare the unit to the approval letter rather than to anyone's memory. If the tenant agreed to restore a wall and did, there is nothing to argue about. If they did not, the letter makes any deduction clear and fair to both sides.
Handled this way, a modification request becomes a chance to keep a good tenant happy, and sometimes to improve the unit at little cost to you.